Back to Directory
Goodfellas Fine Cigars

Goodfellas Fine Cigars

Reviews Summary

The consensus highlights a consistently excellent experience with top-rated cigars, knowledgeable and friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Customers praise the extensive selection, comfortable lounge with amenities like TVs and fireplaces, and the owner's expertise in recommending products. Many appreciate the shop's local charm, clean environment, and personable staff, though some note limited hours. The overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with frequent mentions of repeat visits and strong recommendations.

About This Listing

Wheelchair Accessible

Who Can Play?

Most arcades welcome all ages (some may have age restrictions for certain games)
Minors may need parent/guardian supervision (policies vary by location)
No gaming experience required - games range from beginner to expert level
Comfortable clothing and closed-toe shoes recommended for safety
Valid ID may be required for certain attractions or age verification
Groups and parties welcome (advance booking may be required)

*Note: Age restrictions and policies may vary by arcade. Check with your local facility for specifics.*

First-Time Visitors

First-time visitors may need to sign a waiver or register for a game card. Staff are typically available to help explain games and provide tutorials. Some arcades offer newcomer specials or free play sessions to help you get started.

Common Restrictions:

Age-Based Some games may have height or age requirements for safety reasons
Capacity Popular games may have wait times during peak hours

*Note: Policies vary by arcade. Confirm with your local facility.*

What to Bring

Cash or card for tokens/credits (some arcades are cashless)
Valid ID for age verification or membership signup
Phone to capture high scores and memories (check photo policies)

*Note: Payment methods and requirements may differ by arcade.*

Preparing for Your Visit

Check arcade hours and peak times online before visiting
Eat beforehand or check if the arcade has food options
Bring friends for multiplayer games and competitions
Wear comfortable clothes you can move freely in
Avoid bringing valuable items that could be lost or damaged
Check for special events, tournaments, or discount days
Set a budget for games and stick to it
Stay hydrated, especially during long gaming sessions

*Note: Tips may vary by arcade type and location.*

How to Get Started

Most arcades accept walk-ins, but call ahead during busy periods or for large groups. Check for membership deals!

Other Helpful Info

Most visits last 1-3 hours depending on games and group size
Popular games may have longer wait times during weekends and evenings
Many arcades offer unlimited play packages or time-based pricing
Some locations host tournaments and special events regularly
Prize redemption available at many arcades - save your tickets!

*Note: Policies, pricing, and features differ by arcade. Contact your local facility for details.*

Features

Wheelchair Accessible

Contact Information

Address

160 N Merchant St

Decatur, Illinois 62523

Call Now Get Directions

Hours

Monday 10AM-5PM
Tuesday 10AM-5PM
Wednesday 10AM-8PM
Thursday 10AM-8PM
Friday 10AM-8PM
Saturday 10AM-4PM
Sunday Closed

Customer Reviews

Great little cigar shop with a smoking lounge with TVs, games and fireplace. They also have lockers for rent to store your supplies in to enjoy the evening. Definitely a great one of a kind local hangout spot.

Employees are always kind and knowledgeable. Always a great experience!

Goodfellas is an outstanding local gem! I went in today for the first time looking for advice on how to get started in cigar smoking. The employee, Dustin, was very friendly and helpful to me while I asked my ?newbie? questions. It's so nice to have a local store like Goodfellas. I definitely recommend it!

Excellent selection and great experience of the lounge. Good location in the city

I have been frequenting Goodfellas for about two years now and I have never been disappointed. Great selection of fine cigars and pipe tobacco. The owners is very knowledgeable and is very easy to make a deal with. The atmosphere in the smoker's lounge is inviting and comfortable. I highly recommend, quite frankly this establishment is one the best things in Decatur.

Excellent service, selection, and great vibe! Try it out!

Super welcoming environment. Owner is extremely helpful in helping you find your own palette. I have never been pressured to purchase anything out of my price range. I felt right at home before I left on my very first visit.

Clean place with a good inventory. Prices are about what you expect. Cheaper than lots of places, more expensive than others. Very fair, as you get to physically see what you are buying, talk to the guy working to learn more or get suggestions, and you get instant gratification when you leave with the cigars. I go every so often to get something new, its a great way to find out what you like, and not just order random sticks in the mail that will show up weeks later.

Goodfellas has a great selection of cigars. Really personable and knowledgeable about the products ,they will find you the best cigar for any occasion or celebration. Every cigar is cared for and ready to enjoy, from first light to last puff they've got you covered. Cutters, lighters, ashtrays, etc.

Fantastic shop. Great cigar selection and a really friendly environment. Great place. Been going there for a year and won't be stopping any time soon. Gr8 m8 r8 8/8

Been coming here since I was of legal age to smoke, the owner was more than helpful in getting my hobby started. Still a customer all these years later. Wouldn't recommend anywhere else!

One of Decatur?s gems! The new owner has freshened up the place with new cigars, lockers, and other amenities. Check it out!

Always a great experience. The owner is always on hand to answer your questions. And I go in sometimes not knowing what I want and he always has very good recommendations. He has not ever steered me wrong. And the selection is very good.

I like this place. It is always confusimg to a newbie with the massive amount of choices available but Nate is pretty good at pointing you in the right direction. It has a goid atmosphere and is comfortable.

Nice selection and comfy atmosphere. The people there, patrons and staff are welcoming. Will definitely come back.

Appreciate the Customer Service! Says a lot about Nate, as an owner. Top notch Experience. You'll NEVER find this kind of service and expertise online! #shoplocal

Been going here since I was old enough to smoke cigars, great place and the new owner is a good fit.

Great selection, friendly staff, amazing chairs, and atmosphere.

Nice place with a good selection. Owner seemed friendly enough. Unfortunately I couldn't hang around to smoke.

Excellent selection. Nate is extremely knowledgeable and friendly. Great atmosphere to enjoy a cigar as well.

Clean with excellent smoking environment. Friendly owner. Wish they were open later than 6pm during the week, I would have stayed and smoked another stick.

Cool environment full of cool art, a really nice selection of cigars and related products. It's relaxing with a cool owner.

Goodfellas is a great shop

Great shop, Great Smokes. Atmosphere is Top Notch

Great services, atmosphere and good choice of great smokes. Nate is a great guy. Highly recommend.

A very relaxing shop with a great variety and helpful staff.

Excellent cigars, excellent service. Great place for a novice like me.

Nate is the best! I've never had a bad cigar for Goodfellas!

Always the best service! Nate is a great guy that really knows his stuff!

One of the last places to get a good cigar and sit down to enjoy it.

This is a great cigar shop. I really miss it but i quit smoking.

Best place in town. No pressure to buy and perfect atmosphere.

Awesome place and there will to help u all u need

I've never been disappointed here great smokes

Great selection of cigars in a really cool place

It's the place to go for the best cigar in town

Small shop nice atmosphere

A fantastic tobacco shop with the best cigars around.

HAD A GREAT TIME WITH FRIENDS AND FAMILY AT NATES IN GOODFELLAS!!!!

Brutal hours. Possibly for retired people only? Had to go across town to the liquor store.

Absolutely the best selection of cigars

Most up to date trending cigars in the area

Amazing cigars. Immaculate bathroom.

Great choices to choose from.

(Translated by Google) Super nice employees. Sweet selection?a pair of Plasencia 151s and a Davidoff Colorado Claro. Thank you very much. (Original) Super nice employees. Sweet selection - got a couple Plasencia 151s and a Davidoff Colorado Claro. Mucho gracias.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s it like visiting an arcade today?

It’s a mix of nostalgia and high-energy fun! Many arcades blend retro classics like Pac-Man and pinball with modern VR games, racing simulators, and rhythm challenges — often with music, lights, and a social vibe.

Is it better to go alone or with friends?

Both can be great! Solo visits let you focus on your favorite games, while going with friends adds competition, teamwork, and laughs. Many people plan arcade meetups as a casual hangout or even date spot.

What should I bring to an arcade?

Usually just yourself and a way to pay (some arcades still use coins, others use cards or apps). If you're competitive, bring your A-game. If you're social, bring friends or meet new ones over multiplayer games.

What’s the best time to visit an arcade?

Weekdays or early afternoons are usually less crowded — perfect for focused play. Evenings and weekends bring the buzz, especially at barcades or venues with DJs, tournaments, or themed nights.

Can I meet new people at arcades?

Absolutely! Arcades attract a mix of casual players and serious gamers. Whether you're jumping into a four-player co-op or chatting between rounds, it's a fun, low-pressure way to connect over shared interests.

Are arcades still just for kids?

Not at all. While many arcades are family-friendly, there are also adult-oriented ones with full bars, 18+ nights, or vintage nostalgia themes. Arcades today cater to everyone — from first-timers to lifelong gamers.

Are there events or tournaments I can join?

Yes! Many arcades host regular competitions, retro nights, cosplay parties, and more. Whether you're into high scores or just want to watch and vibe, events add an extra layer to the experience.

What if I’m not great at arcade games?

No worries — arcades are about having fun, not being perfect. Try a variety of games, ask others for tips, and remember: the vibe is more “let’s play” than “let’s win.”