Back to Directory
Carello's Carousel Arcade

Carello's Carousel Arcade

Reviews Summary

Sylvan Beach amusement park receives mixed reviews. Many praise the classic carousel, fun games, and family-friendly atmosphere, calling it a great nostalgic experience. However, several criticize poor customer service, rigged machines, and unfair ticket policies, with some calling the owners rude or the venue run-down. While some visitors love the fair prices and enjoyable time, others feel ripped off by high costs and disappointing prizes. The carousel is consistently highlighted as a standout attraction.

About This Listing

Who Can Play?

Most arcades welcome all ages (some may have age restrictions for certain games)
Minors may need parent/guardian supervision (policies vary by location)
No gaming experience required - games range from beginner to expert level
Comfortable clothing and closed-toe shoes recommended for safety
Valid ID may be required for certain attractions or age verification
Groups and parties welcome (advance booking may be required)

*Note: Age restrictions and policies may vary by arcade. Check with your local facility for specifics.*

First-Time Visitors

First-time visitors may need to sign a waiver or register for a game card. Staff are typically available to help explain games and provide tutorials. Some arcades offer newcomer specials or free play sessions to help you get started.

Common Restrictions:

Age-Based Some games may have height or age requirements for safety reasons
Capacity Popular games may have wait times during peak hours

*Note: Policies vary by arcade. Confirm with your local facility.*

What to Bring

Cash or card for tokens/credits (some arcades are cashless)
Valid ID for age verification or membership signup
Phone to capture high scores and memories (check photo policies)

*Note: Payment methods and requirements may differ by arcade.*

Preparing for Your Visit

Check arcade hours and peak times online before visiting
Eat beforehand or check if the arcade has food options
Bring friends for multiplayer games and competitions
Wear comfortable clothes you can move freely in
Avoid bringing valuable items that could be lost or damaged
Check for special events, tournaments, or discount days
Set a budget for games and stick to it
Stay hydrated, especially during long gaming sessions

*Note: Tips may vary by arcade type and location.*

How to Get Started

Most arcades accept walk-ins, but call ahead during busy periods or for large groups. Check for membership deals!

Other Helpful Info

Most visits last 1-3 hours depending on games and group size
Popular games may have longer wait times during weekends and evenings
Many arcades offer unlimited play packages or time-based pricing
Some locations host tournaments and special events regularly
Prize redemption available at many arcades - save your tickets!

*Note: Policies, pricing, and features differ by arcade. Contact your local facility for details.*

Contact Information

Address

118 Park Ave

Sylvan Beach, New York 13157

Visit Website Call Now Get Directions

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 5-10PM
Thursday 5-10PM
Friday 5-10PM
Saturday 1-10PM
Sunday 1-10PM

Customer Reviews

Today took me three year old daughter to the Sylvan Beach amusement park. We spent $62 for 40 tickets then took a break at the Carmelo arcade where I proceeded to spend another 30$ In games and the 2$ per ride carousel that doesn't even go up and down, The man I bought the tickets from had no customers service manors whatsoever but that wasn't my problem, yet! How ever I spent ten dollars in quarters in one vending machine where you could win rolled up tickets To buy the cheap prizes for the kids! 10$ and I

How can you not love it.This one is like when I was a kid and goes wicked fast. Granddaughter loved it so much my son had the worst time peeling her from it at the end.lol

Carousel is worth the $2 ride, any machine you play in this place is set to take your money and leave you frustrated. Don't even get me started on the claw machines they have in here, numerous times would pick an item up just for it to open the claws before the correct spot it supposed to drop.

Spent a good chunk of cash and had lots of fun. Until the cheap, petty person at the prize counter refused to accept a large number of tickets we'd won because a young child made a mistake. Keep your worthless roll of tickets and 2-cent plastic trinkets. We won't spend another $50. Brilliant business decision on their part.

Place is run down & the owners are miserable towards young children. Save your money and patron somewhere else! Youll spend a fortune and cant get anything for your tickets because the owners have stipulations on the tickets! Horrible

Great arcade! Fair prices and good times for all.

The carousel alone is worth the trip. Various games to play and prizes to win. 3rd generation of visiting Sylvan Beach.

Great historical ride. Worth riding

Fun little arcade with a carousel and games for adults also.

Always a great time .staff very nice and friendly.

Love playing the games for tickets!!

Great place to go play games with the kids

Fun place to take your family

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s it like visiting an arcade today?

It’s a mix of nostalgia and high-energy fun! Many arcades blend retro classics like Pac-Man and pinball with modern VR games, racing simulators, and rhythm challenges — often with music, lights, and a social vibe.

Is it better to go alone or with friends?

Both can be great! Solo visits let you focus on your favorite games, while going with friends adds competition, teamwork, and laughs. Many people plan arcade meetups as a casual hangout or even date spot.

What should I bring to an arcade?

Usually just yourself and a way to pay (some arcades still use coins, others use cards or apps). If you're competitive, bring your A-game. If you're social, bring friends or meet new ones over multiplayer games.

What’s the best time to visit an arcade?

Weekdays or early afternoons are usually less crowded — perfect for focused play. Evenings and weekends bring the buzz, especially at barcades or venues with DJs, tournaments, or themed nights.

Can I meet new people at arcades?

Absolutely! Arcades attract a mix of casual players and serious gamers. Whether you're jumping into a four-player co-op or chatting between rounds, it's a fun, low-pressure way to connect over shared interests.

Are arcades still just for kids?

Not at all. While many arcades are family-friendly, there are also adult-oriented ones with full bars, 18+ nights, or vintage nostalgia themes. Arcades today cater to everyone — from first-timers to lifelong gamers.

Are there events or tournaments I can join?

Yes! Many arcades host regular competitions, retro nights, cosplay parties, and more. Whether you're into high scores or just want to watch and vibe, events add an extra layer to the experience.

What if I’m not great at arcade games?

No worries — arcades are about having fun, not being perfect. Try a variety of games, ask others for tips, and remember: the vibe is more “let’s play” than “let’s win.”